MINUTES OF THE SENATE COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION Sixty-eighth Session June 15, 1995 The Senate Committee on Transportation was called to order by Chairman William R. O'Donnell, at 3:06 p.m., on Thursday, June 15, 1995, in Room 226 of the Legislative Building, Carson City, Nevada. Exhibit A is the Agenda. Exhibit B is the Attendance Roster. COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Senator William R. O'Donnell, Chairman Senator Maurice Washington, Vice Chairman Senator Lawrence E. Jacobsen Senator Jon C. Porter Senator Raymond C. Shaffer Senator O. C. Lee COMMITTEE MEMBERS ABSENT: Senator Joseph M. Neal Jr. (Excused) GUEST LEGISLATORS PRESENT: Assemblywoman Deanna Braunlin, Assembly District No. 4 STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT: Don O. Williams, Chief Principal Research Analyst Diane Rea, Committee Secretary OTHERS PRESENT: Bruce Glover, Chief, Drivers' License Division, Department of Motor Vehicles and Public Safety (DMV&PS) Ben Graham, Lobbyist, Nevada District Attorneys Association Roger Whomes, Deputy District Attorney, Criminal Division, Washoe County District Attorney's Office Laurie Buck, Counsel, Department of Motor Vehicles and Public Safety (DMV&PS) Major Daniel Hammack, Commander, Field Operations Bureau, Nevada Highway Patrol Division (NHP), Department of Motor Vehicles and Public Safety (DMV&PS) Chad Dornsife, Lobbyist, National Motorist Association (NMA) Judy Jacoboni, Lobbyist, Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD) Daryl Capurro, Lobbyist, Nevada Franchised Auto Dealers Association (NFADA) Randall Walker, Clark County Aviation, Las Vegas McCarran International Airport Bob Broadbent, Director of Aviation, Las Vegas McCarran International Airport Donna Wadey-Howell, Acting Chief, Registration Division, Department of Motor Vehicles and Public Safety (DMV&PS) Senator O'Donnell opened the hearing on Senate Bill (S.B.) 322. SENATE BILL 322: Revises requirements for maintaining proof of financial responsibility after reinstatement or restoration of driver's license, permit or registration. (BDR 43- 1468) Don O. Williams, Chief Principal Research Analyst, explained the changes in the amendment to S.B. 322, Amendment No. 891 (Exhibit C). This change is to the reference of a designated agent for the department. Senator O'Donnell stated that the old names are being changed to the new names for clarity. SENATOR WASHINGTON MOVED TO AMEND WITH AMENDMENT NO. 891, AND DO PASS S.B. 322. SENATOR JACOBSEN SECONDED THE MOTION. THE MOTION CARRIED. (SENATORS PORTER, NEAL AND SHAFFER WERE ABSENT FOR THE VOTE.) * * * * * Senator O'Donnell said the committee needs to indefinitely postpone S.B. 64 because it is incorporated into S.B. 322. SENATE BILL 64: Revises provisions relating to reinstatement of certain drivers' licenses which have been revoked or suspended. (BDR 43-572) Bruce Glover, Chief, Drivers' License Division, Department of Motor Vehicles and Public Safety (DMV&PS), testified the department had brought this bill to the Legislature. SENATOR JACOBSEN MOVED TO INDEFINITELY POSTPONE S.B. 64. SENATOR LEE SECONDED THE MOTION. THE MOTION CARRIED. (SENATORS PORTER, NEAL AND SHAFFER WERE ABSENT FOR THE VOTE.) * * * * * Senator O'Donnell opened the hearing on A.B. 258. ASSEMBLY BILL 258: Requires department of motor vehicles and public safety to issue special license plates to retired military persons for support of veterans' cemeteries in Nevada. (BDR 43-1060) There was no testimony for or against this bill. Senator O'Donnell closed the hearing on A.B. 258. Senator O'Donnell opened the hearing on A.B. 336. ASSEMBLY BILL 336: Expands and clarifies authority of municipality to acquire property for municipal airport. (BDR 44-529) Senator O'Donnell said he will hold the hearing on this bill to allow the concerned parties time to come back to the meeting room. Senator O'Donnell opened the hearing on A.B. 530. ASSEMBLY BILL 530: Revises provisions regarding renewal of drivers' licenses. (BDR 43-1146) Assemblywoman Deanna Braunlin, Assembly District No. 4, testified that while campaigning, the most frequently asked question was, "What can we do to shorten the lines at the DMV&PS?" Mr. Glover said the department strongly supports A.B. 530. The department estimates 60 percent of the people will utilize the mail-in program. He provided the committee members with a packet containing items pertaining to the renewal-by-mail program. The packet contained a manila envelope (Exhibit D), and a Mail-In Voter Registration Application (Exhibit E). Mr. Glover estimates 121,746 less people will be visiting the DMV&PS offices. He included the Renewal-By-Mail Information packet (Exhibit F), the Class D Driver's License Renewal Sticker (Exhibit G) and the fiscal note for the bill (Exhibit H). Mr. Glover explained the purpose of the forms. Senator O'Donnell asked if the DMV&PS has the staff to perform this function? Mr. Glover stated DMV&PS believes this can be absorbed in headquarters. He estimates it will take a staff of three people and they are on board now. Senator Jacobsen asked if an "X" will be sufficient for those people who do not write. Mr. Glover stated that DMV&PS does accept an "X." It will have to be notarized. Senator O'Donnell closed the hearing on A.B. 530. Senator O'Donnell opened the hearing on A.B. 643. ASSEMBLY BILL 643: Revises provisions governing testing of driver for presence of alcohol or controlled substance in his blood or breath. (BDR 43- 1811) Ben Graham, Lobbyist, Nevada District Attorneys Association, testified the law in Nevada says it is illegal to drive under the influence (DUI) of alcohol. He explained the purpose of the bill. This statute will equalize a DUI second offense or DUI with substantial bodily harm offense, and remove the right of refusal on a DUI first offense. He said on page 3 line 14 of the current bill the word "may" is taken out and is replaced by "shall." He requested that "may" be left in. Roger Whomes, Deputy District Attorney, Criminal Division, Washoe County District Attorney's Office, said Mr. Gammick, the Washoe County District Attorney, brought this bill to the Legislature to allow for the drawing of blood. This is aimed at the first time offender. Senator O'Donnell said the bill will not change the law on a probable cause to arrest, or the probable cause to ask for a breath test. He said what is being changed is in the felony area of a DUI first-time offense. A blood test may be required even though the driver may not want to give it. Mr. Whomes said not exactly. The law now reads, in a felony area, if you have a second DUI within 7 years, you can take a blood test. What this bill will aim at is the first-time offender who has no felony DUI. He said that person will have to submit to a test even if he refuses. They would still be given the option of a breath or blood test, but they will no longer have the ability to refuse to take a test, as long as the officer has probable cause for the arrest. Mr. Whomes stated that a person with a .09 Blood Alcohol Count (BAC) can be kept under arrest. In Washoe County there is a DWAI (Driving While Alcoholic Impaired) ordinance which is between .05 BAC and .09 BAC. Senator Jacobsen expressed concern for the ambulance driver who takes a blood test at the scene of an accident, and does not have any idea where the sample goes once it is turned over to the police officer. He said he had hopes the responsibilities of taking a sample will be spelled out better. Laurie Buck, Counsel, Department of Motor Vehicles and Public Safety (DMV&PS), testified in support of this bill. She said it removes the taking of a person's license who does not consent to the testing. Senator Jacobsen asked if an officer has the right to take a person's license at the scene of a drunk driving arrest or accident. Ms. Buck responded that the bill says unless there is a breath test result of .10 BAC or greater, the officer cannot take a person's license. Major Daniel Hammack, Commander, Field Operations Bureau, Nevada Highway Patrol Division (NHP), Department of Motor Vehicles and Public Safety (DMV&PS), stated the division supports A.B. 643. He gave an explanation of why and urged the committee's support. Chad Dornsife, Lobbyist, National Motorist Association (NMA), stated his objection to the bill is because it changes "implied consent" to "whatever forcible duress is required" to draw blood or whatever the officer desires to do. Senator O'Donnell asked if the district attorney will have a problem with changing the law to "cause to include the suspect of DUI" instead of just "suspect of" anything? Mr. Whomes replied that the protection is built into the law for that. An officer must have probable cause before they can stop someone. Mr. Dornsife stated people will refuse to take a test for political reasons. He said he thinks for a person to be forcibly held down for a blood test is excessive. Judy Jacoboni, Lobbyist, Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD), said the Lyon County chapter of MADD supports this bill. Eight other states have forced chemical testing for misdemeanor first DUI offense in statute. She stated DUI is the most frequent offense in the United States. Senator O'Donnell asked Ms. Jacoboni and Mr. Dornsife to work out their differences on this bill. Senator O'Donnell closed the hearing on A.B. 643. Senator O'Donnell opened the hearing on A.B. 205. ASSEMBLY BILL 205: Revises provisions regarding sale, lease and registration of motor vehicles. (BDR 43-113) Senator Porter stated that A.B. 447 is being heard on the Assembly side right now and it affects this bill. ASSEMBLY BILL 447: Makes various changes to provisions governing sale of motor vehicles. (BDR 43- 16) Senator O'Donnell stated A.B. 447 is the licensure of auto brokers and A.B. 205 is 180 degrees different from this bill. SENATOR JACOBSEN MOVED TO DO PASS A.B. 205. SENATOR LEE SECONDED THE MOTION. Senator Porter stated page 2 line 8 refers to a new car definition, having 2500 miles or less on the odometer. He said he is to assume that if a customer returns a vehicle with 2500 miles or less to the dealer, that customer will receive a full refund. Senator O'Donnell responded that the law says provided the vehicle has not been registered. Senator Porter said one-half of the statute says that a vehicle is still a new car if the mileage is less than 2500 miles. He said his question is, why is there a need to add 2500 miles if the law says a new vehicle is no longer new once it is registered? And can a consumer return that car before being registered, for a full refund, if it is not damaged? Daryl Capurro, Lobbyist, Nevada Franchised Auto Dealers Association (NFADA), stated this bill changes the law to say the vehicle can go up to 2500 miles and still be considered a new car. That 2500 miles needs to be in there because it determines the difference in a new vehicle and a used vehicle; registered or not. Mr. Capurro said if a person registers a vehicle and drives it for 2500 miles, then wants to return it, there is no guarantee that they are going to ... they have put 2500 miles on the vehicle. Whether or not the person will have a full refund will be a negotiatory process between them and the dealer they brought it from. Senator O'Donnell verified that it is considered a new car until it is registered or has more than 2500-miles. Mr. Capurro said even though it is registered, it is considered a new vehicle until it has over 2500 miles on it. Of the eight states who have a mileage allowance, Nevada is the lowest. Senator Porter said he is uncomfortable with not having a definite explanation of the 2500 mile clause. THE MOTION CARRIED. (SENATORS WASHINGTON AND NEAL WERE ABSENT FOR THE VOTE. SENATOR LEE AND PORTER VOTED NO.) * * * * * Senator O'Donnell opened the hearing on A.B. 461. ASSEMBLY BILL 461: Makes various changes concerning county and municipal airports. (BDR 44-360) Randall Walker, Clark County Aviation, Las Vegas McCarran International Airport, said A.B. 461 does two things. First, it changes the advertising requirement for entering into leases. Secondly, it changes chapter 496 of the Nevada Revised Statutes (NRS) to allow airport employees to gather information on airport property for airport projects. Mr. Walker stated that the bill also changes the period of time for entering into leasing of property from 40 years to 50 years. Senator O'Donnell closed the hearing on A.B. 461. Senator O'Donnell reopened the hearing on A.B. 336. Bob Broadbent, Director of Aviation, Las Vegas McCarran International Airport, said the airport is authorized by law to purchase or condemn property that is needed for future development of the airport, or if it is in high noise areas. Mr. Broadbent said this bill will give the aviation authorities the ability to sell, rent, or move the home. Senator Lee asked if it is possible these houses can accommodate low-income families? Mr. Broadbent said they are working with the Clark County Housing Authority on the acquisition of some of these homes. They will be moved to a new area. He said a mobile home park has to be moved and the housing authority is assisting with that also. Senator O'Donnell closed the hearing on A.B. 336. Senator O'Donnell opened the hearing on A.B. 258. ASSEMBLY BILL 258: Requires department of motor vehicles and public safety to issue special license plates to retired military persons for support of Veterans' cemeteries in Nevada. (BDR 43-1060) Donna Wadey-Howell, Acting Chief, Registration Division, Department of Motor Vehicles and Public Safety (DMV&PS), explained this bill will allow for another set of license plates for persons retired from the armed forces. The money from the plates will go to support the Veterans' cemeteries in Nevada. She said the cost of the sheeting is approximately $3400 per roll, and the DMV&PS will need five rolls to cover this bill. The cost will be $17,000. She said based on the sales from the previous Veterans' plates, she does not think the DMV&PS will make that money back. Ms. Howell stated that a lot of the other states who are dealing with special license plates are putting in a minimum quantity clause. The bill calls for a minimum of 250 plates to be ordered before production. Senator Washington asked if all the other license plate bills heard this session can be amended to say 250 ordered before production? Ms. Howell said she had spoken with the sponsors of the bills and they have told here they do not have a problem with putting in the 250 quantity. Senator O'Donnell closed the hearing on A.B. 258. Senator O'Donnell called for a motion on A.B. 530 to do pass and re-refer to the Senate Committee on Finance, because it has a $30,000 fiscal note. SENATOR LEE MOVED TO DO PASS AND RE-REFER A.B. 530 TO THE SENATE COMMITTEE ON FINANCE. SENATOR WASHINGTON SECONDED THE MOTION. THE MOTION CARRIED. (SENATORS JACOBSEN, PORTER AND NEAL WERE ABSENT FOR THE VOTE.) * * * * * Mr. Dornsife said the only thing he objected to on A.B. 643 is a person being forced into having blood taken. If a breathalyser is available the person should be given that choice. Senator O'Donnell adjourned the meeting at 4:48 p.m. RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED: Diane C. Rea, Committee Secretary APPROVED BY: Senator William R. O'Donnell, Chairman DATE: Senate Committee on Transportation June 15, 1995 Page